|
Post by Emberstar 🔥 on Jul 13, 2020 18:19:56 GMT -5
First it was Firestar then it was Bramblestar next Lionblaze, Twigbranch and Violetshine now it’s a tie between Tigerheart/star, Rootspring and Shadowsight
|
|
|
Post by Emberstar 🔥 on Jul 13, 2020 18:27:24 GMT -5
@fallownose I have a thing for ShadowClan medicine cats, or at least the toms, I absolutely adore Pebble Heart, Runningnose, Littlecloud, and Puddleshine. XD *Ottersplash* That's understandable I hate how much they get dumped on for being perma-queens, but taking care of children is A LOT of work. All those ShadowClan medicine cats are just really reasonable and understanding unlike SOMEONE *cough* (signals to Goosefeather)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 13, 2020 18:29:13 GMT -5
Emberstar 🔥Did you see the way ThunderClan treated Goosefeather? If I was him, I would have left them to rot, just sayin
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 13, 2020 18:31:12 GMT -5
Emberstar 🔥 Did you see the way ThunderClan treated Goosefeather? If I was him, I would have left them to rot, just sayin didnt goosefeather canonically suffer from a form of dementia near the end of his life too? he was being traumatized daily by horrific visions of the past and future that he could do nothing to change, was socially rejected and emotionally mistreated by many of his own clanmates, being stalked by starclan ghosts, and dealing with dementia. i dont blame him for being a wreck in bluestars prophecy
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 13, 2020 18:33:00 GMT -5
Emberstar 🔥 Did you see the way ThunderClan treated Goosefeather? If I was him, I would have left them to rot, just sayin didnt goosefeather canonically suffer from dementia near the end of his life too? he was being traumatized daily by horrific visions of the past and future that he could do nothing to change, was socially rejected and emotionally mistreated by many of his own clanmates, being stalked by starclan ghosts, and dealing with dementia. i dont blame him for being a wreck in bluestars prophecy Same! And he wasn't even that bad in Bluestar's Prophecy, he joked around with Bluekit and Snowkit, and told them stories, and all the while, Moonflower was treating him like a leper and rolling her eyes at him. I actually got angry reading Bluestar's Prophecy because of how disrespectful everyone was to Goosefeather.
|
|
|
Post by Emberstar 🔥 on Jul 13, 2020 19:10:20 GMT -5
Emberstar 🔥 Did you see the way ThunderClan treated Goosefeather? If I was him, I would have left them to rot, just sayin didnt goosefeather canonically suffer from a form of dementia near the end of his life too? he was being traumatized daily by horrific visions of the past and future that he could do nothing to change, was socially rejected and emotionally mistreated by many of his own clanmates, being stalked by starclan ghosts, and dealing with dementia. i dont blame him for being a wreck in bluestars prophecy But he could be at least just a little nicer.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 13, 2020 19:12:02 GMT -5
didnt goosefeather canonically suffer from a form of dementia near the end of his life too? he was being traumatized daily by horrific visions of the past and future that he could do nothing to change, was socially rejected and emotionally mistreated by many of his own clanmates, being stalked by starclan ghosts, and dealing with dementia. i dont blame him for being a wreck in bluestars prophecy But he could be at least just a little nicer. the whole point of his character is a cassandra type driven to distance and spite due to not only a future he cant change but social rejection. his behavior isnt okay, but you could say the same for some much more poorly written characters. goosefeathers tragic fall was excellently done and thoroughly haunting.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Jul 13, 2020 23:02:53 GMT -5
didnt goosefeather canonically suffer from a form of dementia near the end of his life too? he was being traumatized daily by horrific visions of the past and future that he could do nothing to change, was socially rejected and emotionally mistreated by many of his own clanmates, being stalked by starclan ghosts, and dealing with dementia. i dont blame him for being a wreck in bluestars prophecy But he could be at least just a little nicer. Honestly I'm a bit miffed at the whole, everyone treating him like trash in his novella claim? Like it honestly didn't seem that out of the ordinary to me. He acted weird, and people thought he was, and later on he kinda reminds me of those people that walk around with "the end is near" signs on the street. Like I never really found him likable when we first meet him, so I never really cared for him when he was younger too. He chases a kit and causes them to bust their jaw, which is the main reason Crooked's life was so hectic. He tells a supposed bee-brained prophecy that eventually leads to many injured and even his own sister killed, wasn't worth it. And then he quite literally was encouraging a father to murder his own child. Like what even is the point of his powers? It feels like another Yellowfang situation all over again. I highly doubt if he was more accepted social in his clan when he was younger that anything would really change. Because his leader and clanmates believed him enough to risk their lives in a battle for another clan, and only after it fell through did they start to doubt him. I just can't really care much for a character like him, but then again I didn't feel much toward his sister either. Goose just felt like the more unlikable one though.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 13, 2020 23:15:47 GMT -5
But he could be at least just a little nicer. Honestly I'm a bit miffed at the whole, everyone treating him like trash in his novella claim? Like it honestly didn't seem that out of the ordinary to me. He acted weird, and people thought he was, and later on he kinda reminds me of those people that walk around with "the end is near" signs on the street. Like I never really found him likable when we first meet him, so I never really cared for him when he was younger too. He chases a kit and causes them to bust their jaw, which is the main reason Crooked's life was so hectic. He tells a supposed bee-brained prophecy that eventually leads to many injured and even his own sister killed, wasn't worth it. And then he quite literally was encouraging a father to murder his own child. Like what even is the point of his powers? It feels like another Yellowfang situation all over again. I highly doubt if he was more accepted social in his clan when he was younger that anything would really change. Because his leader and clanmates believed him enough to risk their lives in a battle for another clan, and only after it fell through did they start to doubt him. I just can't really care much for a character like him, but then again I didn't feel much toward his sister either. Goose just felt like the more unlikable one though. it simply comes down to goosefeathers experience in his novella feeling like a very personal one to some people. we have his perspective and we know (at least in gc) that he wasnt attempting to alienate anybody- it happened for reasons outside his control, and was put down to him being “weird”. however a person feels about him later in the timeline, a lot of people are going to find gc goose uncomfortably close to home for their own experiences. i do like goose as a character with a tragic descent into semi-madness, but gc goose is special to me for the reason stated above. its not based wholly in rationality but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ it be like that sometimes
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Jul 14, 2020 14:14:13 GMT -5
Honestly I'm a bit miffed at the whole, everyone treating him like trash in his novella claim? Like it honestly didn't seem that out of the ordinary to me. He acted weird, and people thought he was, and later on he kinda reminds me of those people that walk around with "the end is near" signs on the street. Like I never really found him likable when we first meet him, so I never really cared for him when he was younger too. He chases a kit and causes them to bust their jaw, which is the main reason Crooked's life was so hectic. He tells a supposed bee-brained prophecy that eventually leads to many injured and even his own sister killed, wasn't worth it. And then he quite literally was encouraging a father to murder his own child. Like what even is the point of his powers? It feels like another Yellowfang situation all over again. I highly doubt if he was more accepted social in his clan when he was younger that anything would really change. Because his leader and clanmates believed him enough to risk their lives in a battle for another clan, and only after it fell through did they start to doubt him. I just can't really care much for a character like him, but then again I didn't feel much toward his sister either. Goose just felt like the more unlikable one though. it simply comes down to goosefeathers experience in his novella feeling like a very personal one to some people. we have his perspective and we know (at least in gc) that he wasnt attempting to alienate anybody- it happened for reasons outside his control, and was put down to him being “weird”. however a person feels about him later in the timeline, a lot of people are going to find gc goose uncomfortably close to home for their own experiences. i do like goose as a character with a tragic descent into semi-madness, but gc goose is special to me for the reason stated above. its not based wholly in rationality but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ it be like that sometimes Maybe it's because I felt like people were overexaggerating. I actually re-read it the other day out of curiosity and it really isn't as bad as people make it out to be. Especially compared to the childhoods of more prominent characters and how they were treated or alienated. So I've kinda concluded it really does come down to someone's personal feelings.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 24, 2020 18:43:50 GMT -5
Hmm.. Well I have to say it's jayfeather, He was an interesting character he had an interesting power and His chapters were good. Jayfeather kinda acts like me cause yes I'm mostly grumpy at times, Anyway Jayfeather seems to be the most interesting out of the three (no offence to the people that are a fan of lionblaze, dovewing, and hollyleaf)
And then My second favorite is tallstar, He is also a really interesting character and he is very nice to firestar, His super edition never made me bored and never made me skip some pages,
Tallstar never failed me.
I have no third favorite but I might soon maybe I don't know.
|
|