Post by cappuccinokitty on Feb 14, 2020 11:35:26 GMT -5
As the title says really. Seeing as some people dislike them, try to say one good thing about these characters -
I'll start, Mapleshade was the first female villain, and was pretty good in Crookedstars Promise. Thistleclaw um, had Whitestorm? Tigerheartstar has good intentions. Most of the time. Spottedleaf has ~sweet smelling~ fur Crowfeather had an okay super edition Blossomfall was a (kinda) intresting distraction from all the TigerDove drama
Post by TurnipGreens on Feb 14, 2020 11:44:03 GMT -5
Mapleshade - She actually wasn't bad before she lost her kits. She seemed like a kind cat, and a decent warrior.
Thistleclaw - His name is pretty
Tigerheartstar - I love Tigerheartstar! He's so dedicated to Dovewing, and I find that super sweet. I also really love how close he and his siblings were. He's also been great at holding ShadowClan together, after everything they've been through.
Spottedleaf - She was a nice cat while she was alive
Crowfeather - I really like how he went behind Onestar's back, to try and do what was best for everyone involved, and how he tried to make amends with his ThunderClan kits.
Blossomfall - Her name is pretty... I also like how she wanted to find herbs or something to help the sick cats
Post by morningcoffee on Feb 14, 2020 13:37:42 GMT -5
Mapleshade was a convincible villain in OOTS and CP.
Thistleclaw is buff
Tigerheartstar doesn't deserve the hate he gets. He's really not that bad, aside from being pretty abnoxious. I actually enjoyed Tigerhearts Shadow.
Spottedleaf was a good medicine cat, and as Mothflight has already said, sacrificed herself for Firestar's mate.
Crowfeather is a well written, interesting jerk who was super fun in TNP. His argumentative family are such a great contrast to other examples, and gave windclan more spotlight. The conflict with Leafpool created the some of the most iconic scenes in the entire series, The fire scene, Hollyleaf revealing the secret at the gathering. Besides, his SE is great!
Blossomfall might of had a little crush on Ivypool, which was cute.
Post by Card against 2019 on Feb 14, 2020 13:49:42 GMT -5
mapleshade was genuinely a really good villain in crookedstar's promise. it was detailing her completely ridiculous backstory that made her annoying
before the thistlespotted thing was revealed thistleclaw really wasn't that bad as far as warriors villains go. (I don't consider spottedleaf's heart canon btw)
tigertheartstar......uh.....well i guess he didn't have bad intentions most of the time
spottedleaf didn't do anything extremely bad. the worst thing she did was manipulate leafpool, and tbh leafpool shouldn't have been thinking about running off with crowfeather to begin with so she's not totally innocent there
crowfeather was actually pretty likable during the journey imo, it wasn't until the soap opera antics started that he became unlikable
blossomfall was a welcome break from the dovetiger and lioncinder annoyingness and millie definitely did treat her badly at points
Mapleshade really cares about her children and has a lot better (relatively) reason to do what she did than everyone else in the DF Thistleclaw backs up his bluster about being a tough warrior, he did beat a dog to get his warrior name and all Tigerheartstar is good at taking the advice of his Clan as a leader rather than being autocratic Spottedleaf was good at being a medicine cat Crowfeather genuinely admitted his faults and tried to become a better cat Blossomfall is self-aware enough to know it's wrong how she thinks of Briarlight, and she fought with the Clans at the end despite the huge risk to her life
NOTE: Excessively spamming the shoutbox may result in a 24 hour ban. Other forum rules still apply. Please do not advertise by linking other websites. Members are encouraged to report offending content to the moderators by PM.
Headphone Actor: Yeah, I had to work today too lol.
Feb 17, 2020 22:32:20 GMT -5
Artemis Moon: It was Presidents Day? I worked. The only holiday I get off is Christmas.
Feb 18, 2020 17:30:23 GMT -5