|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 11:21:53 GMT -5
Who are your top five favorite, and top five least favorite characters?
Mine are...
Saving the best for last, so I'm going to do my top 5 least favorite
5. Honestly, I'm not sure, like, I don't like Tigerclaw at all, but his POV cracks me up, Hawkfrost, Breezepelt, Darkstripe, and Ashfur are too pathetic to hate. I guess I'll go with Crowfeather or maybe Jayfeather, I'm not sure, but one of those get the number 5 spot 4. Lizardstripe 3. Rainflower 2. Brokenstar 1. Onestar
Now, onto my favorites!
5. Sorreltail or Red Claw from Dawn of the Clans, I can't decide, I guess Sorreltail since she's appeared more than Red Claw. 4. Whitestorm 3. Littlecloud 2. Sandynose 1. Brackenfur
|
|
|
Post by Oceanmist97 on Jan 26, 2020 11:30:11 GMT -5
This one is definitely tough!
Top dislikes:
5.) Crowfeather 4.) Lizardstripe and Rainflower both, all the abusive mothers in general honestly. 3.) Brokenstar and post TPB Tigerstar 2.) Onestar 1.) Leopardstar
Top favorites:
5.) Stonefur 4.) Jayfeather 3.) Whitestorm 2.) Sandstorm 1.) Brambleclaw (not to be confused with Bramblestar!)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 11:38:35 GMT -5
This one is definitely tough! Top dislikes: 5.) Crowfeather 4.) Lizardstripe and Rainflower both, all the abusive mothers in general honestly. 3.) Brokenstar and post TPB Tigerstar 2.) Onestar 1.) Leopardstar Top favorites: 5.) Stonefur 4.) Jayfeather 3.) Whitestorm 2.) Sandstorm 1.) Brambleclaw (not to be confused with Bramblestar!) Oh god, were there more abusive mothers than just Lizardstripe and Rainflower? Like, I understand that Lizardstripe got some kit that wasn't even hers, shoved onto her, ontop of 3 other kits that she didn't even want. But that gave her NO excuse to treat an innocent kit the way she did. I really like Stonefur too He's not in my top 5 favorites, but he could possibly be one of my top 5 RiverClan favorites. RiverClan favorites would be a HARD one though, because there are so many likeable cats in RiverClan.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 11:50:21 GMT -5
top least favorite
1.tigerheart 2.lizardstripe 3.rainflower 4.leafstar 5.tree
top favorite
1.twigbranch 2.needletail 3.pebbleshine 4.sleekwhisker 5.beenose
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 11:54:27 GMT -5
top least favorite 1.tigerheart 2.lizardstripe 3.rainflower 4.leafstar 5.tree top favorite 1.twigbranch 2.needletail 3.pebbleshine 4.sleekwhisker 5.beenose Why don't you like Leafstar? I don't think I've ever seen anyone list Sleekwhisker or Beenose as their favorite characters lol
|
|
|
Post by cappuccinokitty on Jan 26, 2020 11:55:38 GMT -5
Least fave - Rainflower. I hate this cat with a passion. Lionblaze. Heโs unbearable. Dovewing, only during oots and avos though. In tbc sheโs great. Alderheart. Sol. Hailstar Basically the entire cast of Mapleshades vengeance
Faves - Ivypool Squirrelflight Crookedstar
Thereโs more Iโm just tired atm lol
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 12:01:49 GMT -5
Least fave - Rainflower. I hate this cat with a passion. Lionblaze. Heโs unbearable. Dovewing, only during oots and avos though. In tbc sheโs great. Alderheart. Sol. Hailstar Basically the entire cast of Mapleshades vengeance Faves - Ivypool Squirrelflight Crookedstar Thereโs more Iโm just tired atm lol Why don't you like Hailstar? Is it because he allowed Rainflower to change Stormkit's name?
|
|
Aroace
#90ec86
Name Colour
Pineclaw
Pronouns: He/Him or They/Them
|
Post by Pineclaw on Jan 26, 2020 12:10:03 GMT -5
Least favorite, in no specific order because I can't make up my mind: Rainflower or Lizardstripe
Shrewclaw Sandgorse
Ashfur Onestar
And my top favorites:
Littlecloud
Longtail Whitestorm Stonefur Crookedstar
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 12:17:12 GMT -5
Least favorite, in no specific order because I can't make up my mind: Rainflower or Lizardstripe
Shrewclaw Sandgorse
Ashfur Onestar
And my top favorites:
Littlecloud
Longtail Whitestorm Stonefur Crookedstar
Omg, Sandgorse and Shrewclaw were hugee brats. Especially Sandgorse, he's supposed to be this full grown adult, and he's acting towards his SON the way some middle schooler would act towards another middle schooler.
|
|
|
Post by cappuccinokitty on Jan 26, 2020 13:09:20 GMT -5
Least fave - Rainflower. I hate this cat with a passion. Lionblaze. Heโs unbearable. Dovewing, only during oots and avos though. In tbc sheโs great. Alderheart. Sol. Hailstar Basically the entire cast of Mapleshades vengeance Faves - Ivypool Squirrelflight Crookedstar Thereโs more Iโm just tired atm lol Why don't you like Hailstar? Is it because he allowed Rainflower to change Stormkit's name? Okay, maybe not hate, but it was really unfair and cruel to me. Firstly, I remember seeing someone argue (on another forum maybe? I donโt remember) that it was his โpunishmentโ for running away. Rainflower literally encourages him to do stupid things from a young age, he follows a patrol, gets attacked by a bird and runs off to TC territory, and her response is always โIโm lucky to have such a brave, handsome kit.โ Sorry, I realise Iโm sidetracking lol Anyways, secondly, it was his decision, he could of said no, or changed it to something less harsher. He also agrees to let Shellheart mentor Oakpaw, which had obviously been requested for by Rainflower. When Shellheart questions her afterwards about this, she replies that he agreed it made sense for the strongest warrior to train the strongest apprentice. After lots of the warriors demanded that they wanted to take back Sunningrocks, he agreed, attacking TC first, and losing afterwards. Keep in mind, this is winter, RC is well fed, Sunningrocks are cold (so they canโt really do anything with it, because they canโt hunt on that piece of territory anyways.) Why else would he have wanted to fight? To give his clanmates what they wanted even with the risk of unnecessary bloodshed. (I havenโt read CP in a while though so i canโt be sure.) Idk, but he seems like a bit of a pushover to me tbh, especially when it comes to serious matters that are in his own control, he chooses to give his clanmates what they want, but maybe not whatโs best for them.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 13:17:19 GMT -5
Why don't you like Hailstar? Is it because he allowed Rainflower to change Stormkit's name? Okay, maybe not hate, but it was really unfair and cruel to me. Firstly, I remember seeing someone argue (on another forum maybe? I donโt remember) that it was his โpunishmentโ for running away. Rainflower literally encourages him to do stupid things from a young age, he follows a patrol, gets attacked by a bird and runs off to TC territory, and her response is always โIโm lucky to have such a brave, handsome kit.โ Sorry, I realise Iโm sidetracking lol Anyways, secondly, it was his decision, he could of said no, or changed it to something less harsher. He also agrees to let Shellheart mentor Oakpaw, which had obviously been requested for by Rainflower. When Shellheart questions her afterwards about this, she replies that he agreed it made sense for the strongest warrior to train the strongest apprentice. After lots of the warriors demanded that they wanted to take back Sunningrocks, he agreed, attacking TC first, and losing afterwards. Keep in mind, this is winter, RC is well fed, Sunningrocks are cold (so they canโt really do anything with it, because they canโt hunt on that piece of territory anyways.) Why else would he have wanted to fight? To give his clanmates what they wanted even with the risk of unnecessary bloodshed. (I havenโt read CP in a while though so i canโt be sure.) Idk, but he seems like a bit of a pushover to me tbh, especially when it comes to serious matters that are in his own control, he chooses to give his clanmates what they want, but maybe not whatโs best for them. Oh wow, you have a lot of good points Like, I didn't like him at first, when I had only read about him in Battles of the Clans, because I thought it was super cruel that he tried to drown Reedfeather, because Reedfeather was trying to get his kits back. But then, i read Crookedstar's Promise, and I found him to be really nice, but I didn't ever agree with him changing Crookedstar's name. Do you feel the same way about Heatherstar and her changing Deadfoot's name?
|
|
|
Post by Protractor on Jan 26, 2020 13:21:48 GMT -5
There is only a single cat I dislike and that's Onestar
Favourites 1. Graystripe 2. Riverstar 3. Purdy 4. Barley 5. Sol
|
|
|
Post by cappuccinokitty on Jan 26, 2020 13:21:52 GMT -5
Okay, maybe not hate, but it was really unfair and cruel to me. Firstly, I remember seeing someone argue (on another forum maybe? I donโt remember) that it was his โpunishmentโ for running away. Rainflower literally encourages him to do stupid things from a young age, he follows a patrol, gets attacked by a bird and runs off to TC territory, and her response is always โIโm lucky to have such a brave, handsome kit.โ Sorry, I realise Iโm sidetracking lol Anyways, secondly, it was his decision, he could of said no, or changed it to something less harsher. He also agrees to let Shellheart mentor Oakpaw, which had obviously been requested for by Rainflower. When Shellheart questions her afterwards about this, she replies that he agreed it made sense for the strongest warrior to train the strongest apprentice. After lots of the warriors demanded that they wanted to take back Sunningrocks, he agreed, attacking TC first, and losing afterwards. Keep in mind, this is winter, RC is well fed, Sunningrocks are cold (so they canโt really do anything with it, because they canโt hunt on that piece of territory anyways.) Why else would he have wanted to fight? To give his clanmates what they wanted even with the risk of unnecessary bloodshed. (I havenโt read CP in a while though so i canโt be sure.) Idk, but he seems like a bit of a pushover to me tbh, especially when it comes to serious matters that are in his own control, he chooses to give his clanmates what they want, but maybe not whatโs best for them. Oh wow, you have a lot of good points Like, I didn't like him at first, when I had only read about him in Battles of the Clans, because I thought it was super cruel that he tried to drown Reedfeather, because Reedfeather was trying to get his kits back. But then, i read Crookedstar's Promise, and I found him to be really nice, but I didn't ever agree with him changing Crookedstar's name. Do you feel the same way about Heatherstar and her changing Deadfoot's name? Hmm. Iโm guessing that was Tallstarโs revenge? I havenโt read it in ages, but I probably would if I reread it. Wasnโt his original name Hopkit?
|
|
|
Post by Card against Humanity on Jan 26, 2020 13:24:41 GMT -5
favourites: 1. Hollyleaf 2. Ivypool 3. Squirrelflight 4. Grey Wing 5. Jayfeather
least favourites: 1. Ashfur 2. Rainflower 3. Onestar 4. Lionblaze 5. Dovewing
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 13:26:10 GMT -5
Oh wow, you have a lot of good points Like, I didn't like him at first, when I had only read about him in Battles of the Clans, because I thought it was super cruel that he tried to drown Reedfeather, because Reedfeather was trying to get his kits back. But then, i read Crookedstar's Promise, and I found him to be really nice, but I didn't ever agree with him changing Crookedstar's name. Do you feel the same way about Heatherstar and her changing Deadfoot's name? Hmm. Iโm guessing that was Tallstarโs revenge? I havenโt read it in ages, but I probably would if I reread it. Wasnโt his original name Hopkit? Yeah, it was in Tallstar's Revenge, and yes, his original was Hopkit. He didn't seem to mind his name change, but I wonder if Meadowslip was a little offended, like she gave her kit an adorable name like Hopkit, only to have Heatherstar change it to DEADpaw.
|
|
|
|
Post by Protractor on Jan 26, 2020 13:30:03 GMT -5
ChickenOnestar should've just stayed Onewhisker,maybe then Crowfrost would still be alive. Also I noticed your rank is now you being dead,congrats xD
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 13:36:11 GMT -5
Chicken Onestar should've just stayed Onewhisker,maybe then Crowfrost would still be alive. Also I noticed your rank is now you being dead,congrats xD Yep, it seems like I died lol, thanks XD Yeah, not only Crowfrost, but Kinkfur and Wasptail too. So would his and Firestar's friendship. There was absolutely NOTHING wrong with Mudclaw, sure he was aggressive, but only when someone came at him first.
|
|
|
Post by Protractor on Jan 26, 2020 13:39:15 GMT -5
Chicken Onestar should've just stayed Onewhisker,maybe then Crowfrost would still be alive. Also I noticed your rank is now you being dead,congrats xD Yep, it seems like I died lol, thanks XD Yeah, not only Crowfrost, but Kinkfur and Wasptail too. So would his and Firestar's friendship. There was absolutely NOTHING wrong with Mudclaw, sure he was aggressive, but only when someone came at him first. There were other leaders just as aggressive
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 13:46:50 GMT -5
Yep, it seems like I died lol, thanks XD Yeah, not only Crowfrost, but Kinkfur and Wasptail too. So would his and Firestar's friendship. There was absolutely NOTHING wrong with Mudclaw, sure he was aggressive, but only when someone came at him first. There were other leaders just as aggressive Right? Onestar did EXACTLY what Tallstar feared Mudclaw would do. Even if Tallstar thought Mudclaw was too aggressive, there were much better choices than Onestar...like Tornear, he was a little aggressive, but not as much as Mudclaw, and he has also shown to be friendly towards ThunderClan in the past. Not to mention, Mudclaw would probably be more willing to believe the guy he shared a WOMB with over a guy who he didn't even really like, and two ThunderClan cats. The only thing that got Onestar his promotion was his friendship with Firestar and ThunderClan, and he was QUICK to throw that away.
|
|
|
Post by Haze on Jan 26, 2020 13:51:08 GMT -5
Top Dislike 5: Lionblaze 4: Lionblaze 3: Lionblaze 2: Lionblaze 1: Lionblaze
Top Like 5: Shadowsight 4: Puddleshine 3: Billystorm / Hawkfrost 2: Nightcloud 1: Flametail
I might have a thing for Shadowclan medicine cats and I cheated on the 3rd place, sue me.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 13:57:10 GMT -5
Top Dislike 5: Lionblaze 4: Lionblaze 3: Lionblaze 2: Lionblaze 1: Lionblaze Top Like 5: Shadowsight 4: Puddleshine 3: Billystorm / Hawkfrost 2: Nightcloud 1: Flametail I might have a thing for Shadowclan medicine cats and I cheated on the 3rd place, sue me. Aw poor Lionblaze I LOVE ShadowClan medicine cats, I find it a bit funny, how the most aggressive clan, has had the sweetest medicine cats. Runningnose, Littlecloud, Pebble Heart, Puddleshine
|
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 14:07:17 GMT -5
Top fave: 1. Twigbranch 2. Gray Wing 3. Hollyleaf 4. Ivypool 5. Dovewing Least fave: 1. Needletail 2. Skystar 3. Brokenstar 4. Rainflower 5. Raggedstar I forgot about Raggedstar, he's not in my top five favorites, but he was INFURIATING in Yellowfang's Secret. I did like him a little bit when I read about him in another story, I forgot from where, because I thought it was sweet how proud he was of his son. Though, in Yellowfang's Secret, it was annoying and obvious nepotism
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 14:09:01 GMT -5
Least favourite 5. Rainflower 4. Hawkfrost/Blossomfall 3. Onestar 2. Breezepelt 1. Lionblaze
Favourite 5. Crowfeather/Littlecloud 4. Dustpelt 3. Ivypool 2. Jayfeather 1. Firestar
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 14:10:21 GMT -5
Least favourite 5. Rainflower 4. Hawkfrost/Blossomfall 3. Onestar 2. Breezepelt 1. Lionblaze Favourite5. Crowfeather/Littlecloud 4. Dustpelt 3. Ivypool 2. Jayfeather 1. Firestar Blossomfall and her little mate are currently the most annoying cats in ThunderClan at the moment lol
|
|
|
Post by springfoot on Jan 26, 2020 14:15:15 GMT -5
Faves Purdy Jayfeather Squirrelflight Violetshine Needletail
Least faves Tigerheartstar Sol Crowfeather
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 26, 2020 14:20:16 GMT -5
Faves Purdy Jayfeather Squirrelflight Violetshine Needletail Least faves Tigerheartstar Sol Crowfeather I think I might be one of the very few people who likes Tigerheartstar. Like, I don't like how he was towards SkyClan, and how he was a bit of a hypocrite when it came to what he said in Tigerheart's Shadow. But I do love how much he loves his family (Dovewing and their kits, and his littermates) I find it super sweet.
|
|
|
Post by ๐ฃ๐ฒ๐ท๐พ๐ฟ๐ฒ๐ฎ๐ต on Jan 26, 2020 14:50:28 GMT -5
Favorites: Leafstar Skystar Hollyleaf Firestar Daisy
Least favorites: Sleekwhisker Jessy Foxheart Raggedstar Blossomfall
|
|
|
Post by Jayie on Jan 26, 2020 16:03:06 GMT -5
Top five favorites:
1. Jayfeather 2. Squirrelflight 3. Pre-death Yellowfang 4. Mothwing 5. Ivypool
(She didnโt quite make the top five but Bristlefrost is definitely on that favorites list somewhere)
Top five least favorites:
1. Tom 2. Rainflower 3. Goosefeather 4. Ashfur 5. Lizardstripe
|
|