|
Post by *Ottersplash* on Sept 1, 2019 20:06:07 GMT -5
Ashfoot would have been interesting, but I don't think she would have been much stricter than Tallstar. Ashfoot has been shown to be extremely level headed and forgiven. Tallstar might have been chosen because of his affection for Firestar. He's also an expert in having feelings and not acting on them. He, at least, has a strong connection to that family. Feathertail would have been a REALLY interesting judge and I'm surprised she didn't appear? She was Crow's first love AND she was a friend of Squirrelflight's That's true, I like Tallstar, but really at this point, I want to see other WindClan cats haha so even though I mentioned Ashfoot as well, I would've preferred if Deadfoot was there. He hasn't been seen in ages! At least Ashfoot was heavily involved in Crowfeather's Trial. Deadfoot was one of my top five favorite WindClan cats and now he's basically nonexistent, while we've had plenty of Tallstar. Ohh! I didn't even think about Feathertail. Maybe she would've been too soft on them? She's such a sweet, caring cat (except that whole...guilting Squirrelflight thing) that perhaps she wasn't picked because she'd been lenient and biased, what with her relationship to both Squirrelflight and Leafpool? She was really good friends to both of them -- to Squirrelflight in life, and to Leafpool in death. Maybe StarClan took into account her last involvement with the sisters and the kit shenanigans, and decided against it ;p That's true, but I just feel like Ashfoot would have more to say on the matter than Deadfoot? He's an awesome cat (who had a really awesome mate), but I feel like he'd have little opinion on the whole Crow thing other than hitting his head on the ground about his son being dumb Maybe, but they also let Yellowfang judge, who told Squirrelflight she was barren and to take the kits. I have to say, she was my favorite judge in the thing though. She was...oddly reasonable, and I haven't seen my reasonable Yellowfang since she was alive. I will say I'm surprised Feathertail doesn't even make an appearance to greet Squirrel and Leaf considering her friendship, but Ashfur gets to pop up
|
|
|
Post by Sand on Sept 3, 2019 9:09:49 GMT -5
you probably wanna put a spoiler warning yo This. Maybe the WC Gen forums should start using spoiler warnings again in general. Now that SqH has been gotten early it's become spoiler central in some parts. I think folks forgot spoilers must be tagged or something. Common sense— there’s the feature there for a reason. You can view it from the Actions tab and people can still apply the labels if they see something as spoiling content. But if you’re not up for that, just report it and I’ll do it. In the meantime, I’ll go find the thread and re-tag it.
|
|
|
Post by quailberry on Sept 3, 2019 9:49:28 GMT -5
I'm sorry but the Erins had better have a good reason for keeping Ashfur in SC. Either he's possessing Bramble, or StarClan as a whole is morally grey-either way would be fine with me. But for pete's sake, GET HIM OUT OF THERE.
|
|