|
Post by Deleted on Feb 28, 2019 14:44:21 GMT -5
Well...I'm back, and just when I promised to run and never look back. But I decided to come back whenever each Warriors book comes out, state my opinions on a few things, and then leave again. And since I've come back, I might as well make the most of it.
Anyway, I thought of making an unpopular opinions thread, Warriors version. Here are ten of my unpopular opinions on the series (and I'll be adding more if I can remember some), and I'd like to hear yours:
1. Bramblestar's an okay character. I thought he was interesting in The New Prophecy. A Vision Of Shadows, however...he got pretty boring to me. 2. Moth Flight is very meh to me. I feel like her reason for medicine cats not having a mate or kits felt rather lame. 3. I absolutely despise Needletail (though I think several people already do). She's no hero in my eyes. 4. I don't like Tigerheart (not hate him, though, there's a big difference), but I do hope he does okay as leader in Lost Stars. 5. I've kinda liked Lionblaze out of the Three. 6. The warrior code may be flawed, but it does make some sense. Maybe some things about the code can be fixed (especially getting rid of 'The word of the Clan leader is the warrior code'), but I'd keep it mostly the same. 7. I'm fine with the Clans having borders. To me, while open borders can bring in potential Clanmates, it can definitely lead to trouble as well. 8. Of all cats in Mapleshade's Vengeance, I believe the most at fault are Appledusk, Oakstar, and Mapleshade herself. 9. To me, the series ended in The Last Hope. Or heck, maybe even Sunset. 10. The Tribe of Rushing Water still looks interesting to me. 11. I don't hate Crowfeather. He may be a lousy dad, but I don't think he's the worst character in the series.
So how about you? What's your unpopular Warriors opinions?
|
|
Bisexual
#64C7FF
Name Colour
finland
Porgs are love
|
Post by finland on Feb 28, 2019 15:19:38 GMT -5
I dislike Violet X Tree I don't like the concept of fading away.
|
|
|
Post by scint on Feb 28, 2019 18:06:53 GMT -5
I hate the concept of fading away. I love Violetshine x Tree. I despise Rainswept Flower x Jagged Peak and I'm glad it never became canon. (Same applies to Minnowtail x Mousewhisker, actually) AVoS was a good series. Mapleshade is a stupid, stupid cat who brought almost all of her misfortune upon herself. I like Tigerheart. I lovewing Dovewing. Hazeltail x Foxleap is a cute ship (that the human/high school AUs screw up a lot) and it should've become canon. Icecloud should've become Icestar with Hazeltail as her deputy. Berrynose or Whitewing better become leader in the next series. Twigbranch would make an interesting deputy/leader. Crowfeather's Trial was made only to please those who love Nightcloud/Breezepelt and hate Crowfeather. I love Nightcloud but I know she's also partially responsible for the family drama like Crowfeather and Breezepelt are. I don't like Moonflower. I like Goosefeather. Swiftpaw is an immature idiot. Swiftpaw x Brightheart is one of the stupidest ships to exist if you ask me. Bluestar is a good character who is realistic. Snowfur x Thistleclaw is a really dumb ship. Thistleclaw is annoying, so is Snowfur but to a lesser extent. I hate Ivypool. I hate Leafpool. I love Ivytail (ShadowClan one). I blame Leafstar and Juniperclaw for the main SkyClan-ShadowClan conflict. Tigerheart is a good leader and I think everyone is jumping to conclusions after seeing him lead for one fricking book.
I may or may not have more.
|
|
|
Post by kinkajou on Feb 28, 2019 18:11:46 GMT -5
I love Twigbranch Is hating fading unpopular? Because boy do I hate it Rosepetal should be leader after Bramblestar I hate Yarrowleaf Oh and I love OakheartxGraypool and hate OakheartxBluestar And I'm super excited for Redtail's novella
|
|
|
Post by Pince on Feb 28, 2019 23:56:34 GMT -5
I dislike the conflict of parents and their kits after the first series. I love Ivytail. I kinda like Dovewing and Bumblestripe (Slightly better than just being ok) . I love the unusual names like flipkit and Billystorm.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 7, 2019 19:16:37 GMT -5
Bump
|
|
|
Post by kinkajou on Mar 7, 2019 20:21:40 GMT -5
Here's another: I don't rlly like the cover style where there's a big floating cat head and a small scene at the bottom (like the foreign covers and the TBC covers)
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 7, 2019 20:30:51 GMT -5
Here's another: I don't rlly like the cover style where there's a big floating cat head and a small scene at the bottom (like the foreign covers and the TBC covers) I still like those original covers, but I also like the new ones.
|
|
|
Post by owlspots on Mar 9, 2019 14:31:20 GMT -5
Greystripe and Millie shouldn't have been mates. I hate Millie; she favoured Briarlight too much and was a horrible mother to Blossomfall. I hate Daisy for the same reasons and also because she never apologised to Brightheart for making a scene about her scars and honestly isn't a likable character at all. Crowfeather isn't the worst character in the series. Nightcloud is at fault too. Tigerstar 2 shouldn't have become leader. Rowanstar giving up his 9 lives was interesting but I wish it had been for different reasons. Bramblestar supposedly going mad is going to be a stupid plot. I think Tree and Violetshine are cute together. The difference between the relationships of parents and kits in the 1st/2nd arcs and in the 3rd/4th/6th arcs is ridiculous and I wish families weren't constantly split up by disagreements. Snowkit should've lived. Speckletail wasn't bad. Whitestorm's death was unnecessary. Bluestar was one of the best characters in the books and her war on StarClan was the most interesting mini-plot. Mapleshade brought most of her problems on herself, it was largely her own fault that her kits died. Mistystar is too old to be leader, she needs to be killed off. Same with Leafstar. ThunderClan needs to stop giving the high positions (deputy, medcat) to family members of the leader; the entire ThunderClan hp squad is related which is really unfair. Squirrelflight should die, so should Leafpool. Briarlight's death was awfully placed and badly timed, she was really 2-dimensional in the 5th arc. Dovewing leaving ThunderClan for Tigerheart was really hypocritical of her and solidified my dislike of her - she went off at Ivypool for being "disloyal" because she trained in the Dark Forest but jumped at the chance to leave ThunderClan for that idiot. Tigerheart/star is really unlikable. Dawnpelt shouldn't have died. Needletail wasn't a hero, she was manipulative and traitorous and deserved to die. Snowfur and Thistleclaw felt forced, but I don't mind Thistleclaw. Bumblestripe has every right to be mad at Dovewing, she's an idiot to have chosen Tigerheart. Brackenfur and Thornclaw should be dead by now. The fading away concept is really annoying and I hate it. The Erins really didn't do anything with the Three and their powers; they could've used them so effectively to win the battle against the Dark Forest but they did as much as any other warrior. Lionblaze needs to take a damn seat. I love Jayfeather. Berrynose should have died instead of Hazeltail. Toadstep's death was unnecessary, they didn't need to kill him off. The Erins need to bring back the Tribe of Rushing Water. SkyClan feels like an OC FanClan and I wish it had just stayed as four Clans. The "mixed" kittypet/warrior names (Billystorm, Harveymoon, etc) annoy me. Spottedleaf's Heart is literally fanfiction it's not canon at all. The Code has become almost obsolete, everybody's breaking it and not just in small ways like going against the word of your Clan leader like Fireheart did. They need to reinforce the Code and actually bring back the punishments for breaking it from the 1st arc. Ravenpaw should not have died. He should have gotten to live with Barley for a little bit longer. The Erins need to stop reusing mini-plots and come up with something original. The twoleg trap plot was the most original by far.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 9, 2019 14:56:26 GMT -5
Greystripe and Millie shouldn't have been mates. I hate Millie; she favoured Briarlight too much and was a horrible mother to Blossomfall. I hate Daisy for the same reasons and also because she never apologised to Brightheart for making a scene about her scars and honestly isn't a likable character at all. Crowfeather isn't the worst character in the series. Nightcloud is at fault too. Tigerstar 2 shouldn't have become leader. Rowanstar giving up his 9 lives was interesting but I wish it had been for different reasons. Bramblestar supposedly going mad is going to be a stupid plot. I think Tree and Violetshine are cute together. The difference between the relationships of parents and kits in the 1st/2nd arcs and in the 3rd/4th/6th arcs is ridiculous and I wish families weren't constantly split up by disagreements. Snowkit should've lived. Speckletail wasn't bad. Whitestorm's death was unnecessary. Bluestar was one of the best characters in the books and her war on StarClan was the most interesting mini-plot. Mapleshade brought most of her problems on herself, it was largely her own fault that her kits died. Mistystar is too old to be leader, she needs to be killed off. Same with Leafstar. ThunderClan needs to stop giving the high positions (deputy, medcat) to family members of the leader; the entire ThunderClan hp squad is related which is really unfair. Squirrelflight should die, so should Leafpool. Briarlight's death was awfully placed and badly timed, she was really 2-dimensional in the 5th arc. Dovewing leaving ThunderClan for Tigerheart was really hypocritical of her and solidified my dislike of her - she went off at Ivypool for being "disloyal" because she trained in the Dark Forest but jumped at the chance to leave ThunderClan for that idiot. Tigerheart/star is really unlikable. Dawnpelt shouldn't have died. Needletail wasn't a hero, she was manipulative and traitorous and deserved to die. Snowfur and Thistleclaw felt forced, but I don't mind Thistleclaw. Bumblestripe has every right to be mad at Dovewing, she's an idiot to have chosen Tigerheart. Brackenfur and Thornclaw should be dead by now. The fading away concept is really annoying and I hate it. The Erins really didn't do anything with the Three and their powers; they could've used them so effectively to win the battle against the Dark Forest but they did as much as any other warrior. Lionblaze needs to take a damn seat. I love Jayfeather. Berrynose should have died instead of Hazeltail. Toadstep's death was unnecessary, they didn't need to kill him off. The Erins need to bring back the Tribe of Rushing Water. SkyClan feels like an OC FanClan and I wish it had just stayed as four Clans. The "mixed" kittypet/warrior names (Billystorm, Harveymoon, etc) annoy me. Spottedleaf's Heart is literally fanfiction it's not canon at all. The Code has become almost obsolete, everybody's breaking it and not just in small ways like going against the word of your Clan leader like Fireheart did. They need to reinforce the Code and actually bring back the punishments for breaking it from the 1st arc. Ravenpaw should not have died. He should have gotten to live with Barley for a little bit longer. The Erins need to stop reusing mini-plots and come up with something original. The twoleg trap plot was the most original by far. I agree with most of these. I can't find myself liking Dovewing or Tigerheart again after Tigerheart's Shadow, I will never ever like Needletail, and the Clans really need to start enforcing the code that they made a long time ago.
|
|
|
Post by ๐ฃ๐ฒ๐ท๐พ๐ฟ๐ฒ๐ฎ๐ต on Mar 9, 2019 14:59:17 GMT -5
I don't like Ivypool and I tend to like the more morally ambiguous characters like Skystar and Needletail. I also love SkyClan, and I think Dovewing leaving was best for everyone. I also don't like TPB.
|
|
|
Post by Sea Drops by a Bird on Mar 9, 2019 15:06:02 GMT -5
Spottedleaf should have lived- I always liked her and Firestar. I think there would have been actual potential for the love that never was and he and the love triangle would have been an actual love triangle.
|
|
|
Post by mymerlincat on Mar 9, 2019 18:11:12 GMT -5
Tigerheart and Bramblestar kick ass and Squirrelflight and Ivypool are whiny and annoying
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 9, 2019 22:31:01 GMT -5
It was not out of character for Dovewing to leave.
I hate Ivypool with a burning passion and I hope she won't become deputy. She was borderline abusive with Tigerheart, no excuse.
|
|
|
Post by Dancing_Totodile on Mar 10, 2019 11:13:33 GMT -5
Fading away and being able to be killed once dead is horrid.
|
|