Post by Holy Fern on Nov 29, 2016 23:23:01 GMT -5
I personally dislike Goosefeather very much. I don't want him to go to the Dark Forest, but I believe that he should regret some of the bad things he has done.
First of all, he is responsible for Crookedkit's injury. He chased a kit, that's right, a kit, just to get it off ThunderClan territory. Crookedkit was a kit, so of course he wouldn't have much common sense to go onto ThunderClan territory. But Goosefeather didn't need to chase them! He could have simply given them a stern warning. He can chase a warrior out of his territory, but why a kit?! And medicine cats are supposed to heal injuries, not cause them. So technically, it's Goosefeather's fault that Stormkit was renamed Crookedkit, because of a broken jaw. (Yes, i also hate Rainflower a lot). Its also Goosefeather's fault that so many of Crookedstar's close family died. If Crookedkit hadnt been injured, Mapleshade wouldn't have come to him and asked if he promised to be loyal above his Clan to all. Crookedkit wanted to prove himself, despite his injury, that he was a loyal cat, so of course he said yes! But then, the promise was taken literally, so Crookedstar's family died. Plus, that is the reason stupid Rainflower rejected him.
Also, Goosefeather caused trouble with WindClan. He claimed that the fact that a piece of prey had blown fur on one side and straight fur on the other side meant that WindClan was bound to cause trouble. He demanded that they attacked immediately, before WindClan attacked. But there had been no sign of hostility between ThunderClan and WindClan. Still, he wanted the Clan to steal their herbs. Moonflower tried to, but BAM. She was killed by Hawkheart, another bad medicine cat. Honestly, I think Hawkheart didn't need to kill Moonflower. Just fight her off. Medicine cats are not supposed to kill, so this drove me more insane than I already am. So Goosefeather, blind to reality, is basically the cause of Moonflower's death. There had been no trace of tension between ThunderClan and WindClan, so he should have at least told the Clan to be cautious instead of telling them to downright attack for no good reason but a silly piece of fresh-kill. So he is the cause of the tension between ThunderClan and WindClan!
So, this is why I hate Goosefeather. What do you think?
First of all, he is responsible for Crookedkit's injury. He chased a kit, that's right, a kit, just to get it off ThunderClan territory. Crookedkit was a kit, so of course he wouldn't have much common sense to go onto ThunderClan territory. But Goosefeather didn't need to chase them! He could have simply given them a stern warning. He can chase a warrior out of his territory, but why a kit?! And medicine cats are supposed to heal injuries, not cause them. So technically, it's Goosefeather's fault that Stormkit was renamed Crookedkit, because of a broken jaw. (Yes, i also hate Rainflower a lot). Its also Goosefeather's fault that so many of Crookedstar's close family died. If Crookedkit hadnt been injured, Mapleshade wouldn't have come to him and asked if he promised to be loyal above his Clan to all. Crookedkit wanted to prove himself, despite his injury, that he was a loyal cat, so of course he said yes! But then, the promise was taken literally, so Crookedstar's family died. Plus, that is the reason stupid Rainflower rejected him.
Also, Goosefeather caused trouble with WindClan. He claimed that the fact that a piece of prey had blown fur on one side and straight fur on the other side meant that WindClan was bound to cause trouble. He demanded that they attacked immediately, before WindClan attacked. But there had been no sign of hostility between ThunderClan and WindClan. Still, he wanted the Clan to steal their herbs. Moonflower tried to, but BAM. She was killed by Hawkheart, another bad medicine cat. Honestly, I think Hawkheart didn't need to kill Moonflower. Just fight her off. Medicine cats are not supposed to kill, so this drove me more insane than I already am. So Goosefeather, blind to reality, is basically the cause of Moonflower's death. There had been no trace of tension between ThunderClan and WindClan, so he should have at least told the Clan to be cautious instead of telling them to downright attack for no good reason but a silly piece of fresh-kill. So he is the cause of the tension between ThunderClan and WindClan!
So, this is why I hate Goosefeather. What do you think?
