|
Post by Bramblestar on Sept 8, 2016 19:54:35 GMT -5
Destroy one of the clans, which one would it be? And why? (Starclan is a choice also).
|
|
|
Post by SilverHailstorm on Sept 8, 2016 20:12:43 GMT -5
Destroy ThunderClan so that readers would be able to actually get a different, non-ThunderClan POV.
|
|
|
Post by theRavenflight on Sept 8, 2016 20:21:10 GMT -5
Destroy the Tribe (if that counts), otherwise WindClan
|
|
|
Post by Bramblestar on Sept 8, 2016 20:28:00 GMT -5
Destroy the Tribe (if that counts), otherwise WindClan Yeah, the tribe counts. But why?
|
|
|
Post by theRavenflight on Sept 8, 2016 22:22:16 GMT -5
Honestly, I never saw the point to them. I always thought that the books where the cats go to the Tribe (i.e. Moonrise, Outcast, and Sign of the Moon) are the most boring and the plot is always repetitive. The cats go to the Tribe because something is wrong back home. Sure, they were an interesting concept, but after a while they were like an unnecessary plot device used whenever something needed to happen in the story.
I do think that the Tribe in Dawn of the Clans is interesting, and that the Tribe could have been a lot more..I don't know...developed, but...after a while, I would be like "Oh no, the Clans are visiting the Tribes AGAIN" and I would dread it. So yeah, that's why I would get rid of the Tribe.
|
|
|
Post by rose on Sept 9, 2016 14:02:46 GMT -5
SkyClan. I found that they weren't necessary to the plot what so ever and were just there so the Erins could get a few more books out. SkyClan's Destiny was one of the most boring books I've ever read, to be honest.
|
|
|
Post by Uмвяᴀ on Sept 10, 2016 17:39:40 GMT -5
The tribe. I do not want anymore mountain journeys.
|
|
|
|
|
Post by wheeledwarrior on Nov 17, 2016 23:37:01 GMT -5
Starclan, just because it would be interesting to see what the cats would do without them (with a completely fall apart, with a star making their own decisions, would they start not being so fatalistic)
Actually, there was a fan fiction that did this, and the results were quite interesting... Something new was born in the end, but the consequences and the sacrifices required to get there were immense...
|
|
|
Post by whiteflight on Nov 18, 2016 14:27:37 GMT -5
Skyclan I found it that we really didn't need them in the plot plus I'm also getting annoyed that they're mostly always in trouble or they get kicked out from their home. I understand why but it's just stupid.
|
|
Bisexual
#e0a8ff
Name Colour
🎃❅❖.Şp໐໐kฯຟiຖ໓.❖❅🎃
THIS IS THE THRILLLLLLLLLLERRRRRRR, THRILLLERRRRR NIIIIIGHHHHTTTT 🎃
|
Post by 🎃❅❖.Şp໐໐kฯຟiຖ໓.❖❅🎃 on Nov 19, 2016 0:10:41 GMT -5
I wanna say StarClan but leaders need their lives :') ThunderClan because lol can we please not focus on these guys anymore?? this series would have been better if they switched a pov every series rather than ... never.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 19, 2016 0:41:29 GMT -5
I wanna say StarClan but leaders need their lives :') ThunderClan because lol can we please not focus on these guys anymore?? this series would have been better if they switched a pov every series rather than ... never. i agree the only time they ever really did a non thunder pov in the main plot that i remember,was Flametail in shadowclan and that lasted like four chapters and then they killed of Flametail,though everyone would be mad because their favorite cats are in there but more people would like cats from other clans if they got developed more.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 29, 2016 8:28:55 GMT -5
Tc because well i dont like em
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 29, 2016 15:36:18 GMT -5
❈ -- ThunderClan's too heroic. Geez like give the other clans a chance. Rowanstar grunted dismissively. “ThunderClan cats always think they are blessed, even when they’re half-starved in leaf-bare.”
|
|
|
Post by Owlmoon on Dec 13, 2016 21:28:20 GMT -5
BloodClan, if it counts. Then ShadowClan.
|
|
Asexual
max
"Gay."
|
Post by max on Dec 22, 2016 10:38:54 GMT -5
Thunderclan should have perished in the fire that took Yellowfang. They should all die.
|
|
Bisexual
Snowfire
Pronouns: She/Her or They/Them
|
Post by Snowfire on Dec 23, 2016 9:43:07 GMT -5
ThunderClan. Honestly, Onestar did have a point when he mentioned that ThunderClan acts superior. All the "heroes" are ThunderClan cats, and it's always ThunderClan coming up with something. Plus, all of the three were ThunderClan. Come on, Erins. ThunderClan isn't the only Clan in the forest. The prophecy would've been more interesting if the three was one cat from each Clan, then the fourth rising from the one Clan who previously didn't have one (Like, the prophecy with the cats with the power of the stars.) ThunderClan always watched over the other Clans as if they own them, and interferes with their problems. ThunderClan, stop. You need put in your places imo. It's alright to be helpful but ThunderClan takes it way too far.
|
|
|
Post by ≈ rippleheart ≈ on Dec 26, 2016 19:49:54 GMT -5
To be honest, we could do without BloodClan - they only lasted for the final fifth of a book, and had almost no lasting impact on the narrative itself... they amounted to pretty much nothing. Also, BloodClan spawned much more terrible than good, what with all the edginess that Clan entailed, as well as... whatever Scourge did to the fandom. Wars over the color of his collar, "misunderstood baby" apologists, a subverted climax that made the books postpone the epic battle we'd been waiting 6 books for to 4 whole series away from the beginning, until pretty much no one cares anymore because of the huge influx of new characters, locations, and conflicts... and the new element of unrealism that BloodClan brought with them, like having dog teeth and claws somehow fit over their own claws and through their collars. They sound cool for about 5 minutes after you hear about them, but the novelty wears off quick if there's no development done for them and they remain an enigma. It would've been nice to see them make a real comeback somehow, and develop into a new challenging recurring antagonist for another arc later on, but at the same time, it might be best if it just stays in The Darkest Hour where it belongs.
The Tribe of Rushing Water was pretty tiring and pointless, too. I actually stopped reading the books for quite a while when I got to the Tribe journey in Outcast... it's just that uninteresting. It's not a culture that we have to worry about ever, since they've always been living separately from the rest of the Clans, and have very little to do with them. Feels like a filler group, or a group that only really exists to provide "some variety" to feline groups, which we... don't really need. At all.
Rant over; final answer is probably to destroy BloodClan, so we can get rid of all the "Scourge's daughter/son/mate" OCs. The rest of the Clans are perfectly fine in my book, and it'd be a shame to totally eradicate any one of them.
|
|
|
Post by Stoneflower on Jan 8, 2017 16:10:45 GMT -5
skyclan. They where never meant to come back. It would be much for interesting if they were a legend or conspiracy.
|
|
|
Post by Dawnrose on Feb 1, 2017 17:01:15 GMT -5
SkyClan. I feel like it was unnecessary to the plot. There should've just been 4 clans in the beginning, and nothing would change that. I feel like Firestar's Quest would still be good to write without SkyClan in it, since the Erins could've made StarClan send out a false sign.
|
|
|
Post by rainstorm5 on Apr 2, 2017 8:26:19 GMT -5
RiverClan
I hate this clan and the whole story would be better without them
|
|
|
Post by Card against Humanity on Apr 2, 2017 9:35:38 GMT -5
I cant decide between Bloodclan and The Tribe
I remember a poll a few months back that asked what your favourite clan was, and I mentioned not having an opinion on Bloodclan because they were too bland and generic for me to muster up any real feelings on them. I stand by that. I'd be willing to bet a lot of money on Blodclan being added in as a afterthought, like the erins thought "HEY maybe we should have all the clans team up to defeat another eVIL CLAN" and wrote bloodclan in at the last second Not only that, but its because Bloodclan exists that Scourge exists, and Scourge fangirls are some of the most annoying people In this fandom, I must say.
The Tribe are also really useless, even though they're in the books much more then Bloodclan. Like others said, they're really just there to be a filler group and a thinly-veiled metaphor for First Nations. Actually, I'd say they're even more useless then Bloodclan, because Bloodclan atleast were antagonists in the last book. The Tribe just don't matter at all.
So, yeah, I cant decide between them. I guess I'll go with Bloodclan, since the Tribe seems more salvageable. All the other clans, even the ones I dislike for the most part [skyclan, windclan] could easily be fixed with competent writers [ie not the Hunters]
|
|
|
Post by Tas on Apr 2, 2017 11:49:38 GMT -5
StarClan.
|
|