|
Post by Deleted on Jul 24, 2017 16:20:30 GMT -5
I kind of feel bad for Cinderheart. So I'm rereading OotS, and I forgot what she went through. She lost Honeyfern, watching her die while not able to do anything to help her, she was constantly worried about Ivypool, who kept getting injuries and she also worried about her jealousy for Dovewing, she wasn't sure who she really was when Jayfeather told her that she is Cinderpelt, and had to relive all of the emotions she had gone through in her dream.
I have always liked Cinderheart, even if she is bland. She's a supportive character who clearly cares for her friends and family, she's a worrywart, especially when it comes to Lionblaze and Ivypool. She balances out the relationship with Lionblaze, trying to remind him to not be so hot-headed or throw himself into battles anymore since he no longer has his powers. I think she is a good match for him, she supports him and calms him down when he needs her. She is also patient with him. I also really liked how they named their kits after their deceased Clanmates.
I also liked her friendship with Hollyleaf. They were both supportive of each other, and Cinderheart was wise beyond her years (but this is only because of her possession from Cinderpelt).
It's a shame she's hardly around now, and I forget that they sometimes even have a litter. I really like Cinderheart, I wish they developed her more, and wrote the "reincarnation" better.
|
|
|
Post by Jei-Dinofelini on Jul 25, 2017 16:56:03 GMT -5
I agree with you. I like Cinderheart for the same reasons you have specified. I am not quite sure why many people seem to hate her or call her a Mary Sue. She isn't one. She is not perfect. She has flaws.
I like her character. There is nothing to hate about her.
It is sad indeed that she doesn't appear much as she I'd in past...
Also that kind of annoys me is that her kits are barely in the story. I just know their names amend that's it. They are there but at same time they are dress not. Just no personality in them. It makes things rather disappointing.... i was expecting more than that. I know that they are background characters but really... they should be more than what they are portrayed as.
Many characters have suffered alot when it comes to spotlight in the new series. I have noticed that there are quite few cats that are mentioned in the allegiances but never mention in the story itself... i wonder why... Maybe later on we seem more of them...
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Jul 26, 2017 10:01:42 GMT -5
I actually prefer Cinder x Holly over any other pairing involving them, even though I was never a big fan of her character, especially with the reincarnation mess.
|
|