Post by Firestone on Feb 26, 2017 9:22:40 GMT -5
After reading Mapleshade's Vengeance, I found it interesting that she seemed to be the one who had the worse final outcome for having a relationship with another Clan's cat. So I did some analysis to 4 cross-Clan lovers that have detailed description, and see why Mapleshade deserved the worse final outcome.
● Appledusk had accidentally killed Oakstar's son. Thinking the kit's father is the one who killed his son, Oakstar banished Mapleshade as well as her kits, which is rare since kits are usually considered innocent plus a Clan would never thought they have too much kits to become Warriors.
● Mapleshade's kits were half-Clan was discovered and revealed by Ravenwing, ThunderClan's Medicine cat.
● Mapleshade's kits were dead during river crossing. Appledusk was mad at it that he deserted Mapleshade.
Point 4:Did the kits die?
Point 5:How did all the forbidden couples deal with they cheat?
2. If you are strongly considered to become the next Clan leader or Medicine cat.
3. You are already on the seat of Medicine cat or Clan leader so everything happened are held in your paws.
4. Don't let the kits die.
5. If the Medicine cat or Clan leader is your kin.
6. You may lose your mate or your kits, so that you'll suffer a lot that the Clan leader would think you've been punished enough with no need to banish you.
● Appledusk had accidentally killed Oakstar's son. Thinking the kit's father is the one who killed his son, Oakstar banished Mapleshade as well as her kits, which is rare since kits are usually considered innocent plus a Clan would never thought they have too much kits to become Warriors.
Point 1:Did the one in love with the ThunderClan cat have any personal enmities with other ThunderClan cats?
Mapleshade & Appledusk | Bluestar & Oakheart | Graystripe & Silverstream | Leafpool & Crowfeather |
Yes | No | No | No |
Point 2:Why were there no punishments after forbidden relationships were revealed?
─ Mapleshade:Banished.
─ Appledawn:Darkstar thought the loss of the kits already did.
─ Bluestar:She's the Clan leader herself. Also, she's dead before things revealed.
─ Oakheart:Crookedstar's his brother.
─ Graystripe:Bluestar had done the same before. Also, she thought the loss of Silverstream already did.
─ Silverstream:Dead before things revealed.
─ Leafpool:Firestar thought the loss of Hollyleaf and her favorite job as a Medicine cat already did.
─Crowfeather:(Unknown)
─ Mapleshade:Banished.
─ Appledawn:Darkstar thought the loss of the kits already did.
─ Bluestar:She's the Clan leader herself. Also, she's dead before things revealed.
─ Oakheart:Crookedstar's his brother.
─ Graystripe:Bluestar had done the same before. Also, she thought the loss of Silverstream already did.
─ Silverstream:Dead before things revealed.
─ Leafpool:Firestar thought the loss of Hollyleaf and her favorite job as a Medicine cat already did.
─Crowfeather:(Unknown)
● Mapleshade's kits were half-Clan was discovered and revealed by Ravenwing, ThunderClan's Medicine cat.
Point 3:Did the Medicine cat from the she-cat's Clan notice there are half-Clan kits? And did he/she revealed that?
Mapleshade | Bluestar | Silverstream | Leafpool |
Yes / Yes | Yes / No | No / No | Yes / No |
● Trivia for point 2
─ If Goosefeather had revealed, Bluestar wouldn't become leader and ThunderClan would be ruined by Thistleclaw.
─ If Goosefeather had revealed, Bluestar wouldn't become leader and ThunderClan would be ruined by Thistleclaw.
─ It is revealed after Silverstream died.
─ Leafpool's the Medicine cat herself.
─ Leafpool's the Medicine cat herself.
● Mapleshade's kits were dead during river crossing. Appledusk was mad at it that he deserted Mapleshade.
Point 4:Did the kits die?
Mapleshade & Appledusk | Bluestar & Oakheart | Graystripe & Silverstream | Leafpool & Crowfeather |
Yes | With 2 of 3 survived | No | No |
Point 5:How did all the forbidden couples deal with they cheat?
─ Mapleshade, Appledawn, and Reedshine were all together at the moment, alive and well for a triangular love to form.
─ Blustar and Oakheart didn't have mates, neither at the moment they were together nor after they broke up.
─ The relationship between Graystripe and Silverstream was terminated because of her death.
─ Leafpool's not allowed to have a mate, thus, no issues about cheating. For Crowfeather, we don't know what's in Nightcloud's mind about that...
─ Blustar and Oakheart didn't have mates, neither at the moment they were together nor after they broke up.
─ The relationship between Graystripe and Silverstream was terminated because of her death.
─ Leafpool's not allowed to have a mate, thus, no issues about cheating. For Crowfeather, we don't know what's in Nightcloud's mind about that...
Conclusions
─Tips o have a forbidden love with cats from another Clan─
1. Choose the cat to be in love wisely.2. If you are strongly considered to become the next Clan leader or Medicine cat.
3. You are already on the seat of Medicine cat or Clan leader so everything happened are held in your paws.
4. Don't let the kits die.
5. If the Medicine cat or Clan leader is your kin.
6. You may lose your mate or your kits, so that you'll suffer a lot that the Clan leader would think you've been punished enough with no need to banish you.