|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Feb 26, 2017 6:38:42 GMT -5
So since I'm not welcomed on certain threads.
Lets talk about the current deputies of each clan.
ThunderClan: Squirrelflight RiverClan: Reedwhisker ShadowClan: Tigerheart WindClan: Harespring SkyClan: Hawkwing
Do any of you think any of these cats will make it to leadership? If so who do you think their deputy of choice will be. If not who do you think might replace them instead. And what's your overall opinion of them, as possible leaders, etc.
Personally I don't think Squirrelflight will make it to leadership, and I'm betting on Ivypool on replacing her. And if Ivystar happens, then maybe Berrynose as her deputy? If he's not too old by then.
I don't care much for Reedwhisker's character, we barely see much of him, he needs more personality. Maybe being leader one day will help, if it were up to be Beetlestar would be a thing. But he's dead, and Mistystar is the oldest cat in the forest. So Reedstar will most likely happen, and for his deputy, maybe Icewing?
Rowanstar doesn't even look like he'll last long, he's probably lost some lives from the sickness, but I'm not big on Tigerstar happening. It probably will anyways, but I'd prefer Tawnystar, Dawnpelt or Strikestone. Anyone of them as deputy would work too, mostly down for Strikestone.
I don't mind Harestar, it's a funny name though. Deputy wise Heathertail or Sedgewhisker maybe? I don't think Onestar has much longer anyways, he's already going crazy.
Hawkwing will most likely become Hawkstar, because I can't imagine Leafstar surviving by the end of the arc. Deputy wise maybe Sandynose or Harrybrook. I would have preferred Stormheart to Harrybrook though.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 26, 2017 6:56:47 GMT -5
3/5 of these deputies are young and I like that very much as the current leaders are old and pretty tiring. Plus they all are already explored charecters we don't need to see more of.
Also , Reedwhisker will probably succeed Mistystar. I mean I don't really see it but knowing the erins it will happen. I cant see Squirrelflight as a leader. Im waiting for her death slowly. Im not too fond of her anyways. As on the other hand.
Leafpool is also going to get old soon. I can see that she will probably retire soon.
|
|
|
Post by Moonblazer on Feb 26, 2017 7:35:36 GMT -5
I adore the idea of Ivystar with Berrynose as her deputy. Absolutely adore it!
I was always hoping for Tawnystar, and I still hope for it. Rowan and Tiger both die and Starclan chooses her, bang, 10/10 would read again.
I'd like to see Reedstar, he seems like a decent deputy!
Team Emberfoot for Windclan Deputy XD
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Feb 26, 2017 9:06:18 GMT -5
I adore the idea of Ivystar with Berrynose as her deputy. Absolutely adore it! I was always hoping for Tawnystar, and I still hope for it. Rowan and Tiger both die and Starclan chooses her, bang, 10/10 would read again. I'd like to see Reedstar, he seems like a decent deputy! Team Emberfoot for Windclan Deputy XD Emberfoot seems like an interesting choice, Emberstar sounds really rad tbh. I can dig it. I want Tawnystar too, but knowing the Erins, Tigerheart won't kick the bucket any time soon, especially with an SE coming. A person can dream. I'm a bit curious for Reedstar too, I want to see more of his personality. He's always seemed like a shadow tbh...just there not doing much.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Feb 26, 2017 9:09:30 GMT -5
3/5 of these deputies are young and I like that very much as the current leaders are old and pretty tiring. Plus they all are already explored charecters we don't need to see more of. Also , Reedwhisker will probably succeed Mistystar. I mean I don't really see it but knowing the erins it will happen. I cant see Squirrelflight as a leader. Im waiting for her death slowly. Im not too fond of her anyways. As on the other hand. Leafpool is also going to get old soon. I can see that she will probably retire soon. Yeah, the Erins need to make way for more younger cat, the next generation that is. I'm still disappointed at them killing off young cats with good potential, like Foxleap, Icecloud, Toadstep, and Hazeltail. Imo I felt their deaths were unnecessary. If Hazeltail or Foxleap were still alive, I would have liked one of them for deputy if not Ivypool. Has Reedwhisker ever really done anything significant in the series ever since he was saved as a kit? If Leafpool kicks the bucket, TC will still have Jay and Alder, so really her death wouldn't necessarily affect the plot much.
|
|
|
Post by Moonblazer on Feb 26, 2017 10:06:59 GMT -5
I was so upset when they killed Toadstep and Icecloud. They had great potentials and I loved every scene Icecloud was in. ;.;
But yeaaaa. Emberfoot for some reason really tickles my fancy! I dunno why, but I feel like he'd be a pretty cool leader or deputy.
|
|
|
Post by Dawnrise on Feb 26, 2017 12:47:37 GMT -5
Squirrelflight will probably die before Bramblestar, so I'd like to see Cherryfall as deputy, she seemed cool in TAQ. Mistystar pretty much has to die in this arc, so we're probably getting Reedstar. Petalfur seems like a good choice, I guess, she showed leadership qualities in The Fourth Apprentice. I'm fine with a Tigerstar 2.0, but Dawnstar of Tawnystar seem cooler.(And then Bramble and Tawny will be leaders together) Harespring is a much better leader than Onestar, so I'm cool with Harestar, with either Heathertail, Breezepelt, or Crowfeather as deputy. I thing Hawkstar is probably the best cat to rebuild SkyClan, and Sandynose seems like a good deputy.
|
|
|
|
Post by Owlmoon on Feb 26, 2017 18:01:42 GMT -5
I was so upset when they killed Toadstep and Icecloud. They had great potentials and I loved every scene Icecloud was in. ;.; But yeaaaa. Emberfoot for some reason really tickles my fancy! I dunno why, but I feel like he'd be a pretty cool leader or deputy. Icecloud...oh I loved her.... Heathertail for WindClan deputy. Reedwhisker for RiverClan deputy. Ivypool for ThunderClan. Tawnypelt for ShadowClan. SkyClan I like Hawkwing.
|
|
|
Post by Moonblazer on Feb 26, 2017 18:04:15 GMT -5
I was so upset when they killed Toadstep and Icecloud. They had great potentials and I loved every scene Icecloud was in. ;.; But yeaaaa. Emberfoot for some reason really tickles my fancy! I dunno why, but I feel like he'd be a pretty cool leader or deputy. Icecloud...oh I loved her.... Heathertail for WindClan deputy. Reedwhisker for RiverClan deputy. Ivypool for ThunderClan. Tawnypelt for ShadowClan. SkyClan I like Hawkwing. I like this lineup greatly! :3 Tawnystar and Ivystar are my dream come true.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Feb 26, 2017 20:12:32 GMT -5
Squirrelflight will probably die before Bramblestar, so I'd like to see Cherryfall as deputy, she seemed cool in TAQ. Mistystar pretty much has to die in this arc, so we're probably getting Reedstar. Petalfur seems like a good choice, I guess, she showed leadership qualities in The Fourth Apprentice. I'm fine with a Tigerstar 2.0, but Dawnstar of Tawnystar seem cooler.(And then Bramble and Tawny will be leaders together) Harespring is a much better leader than Onestar, so I'm cool with Harestar, with either Heathertail, Breezepelt, or Crowfeather as deputy. I thing Hawkstar is probably the best cat to rebuild SkyClan, and Sandynose seems like a good deputy. If Breezepelt became deputy, I wonder how that would play out? Would becoming deputy change him for the better? Or maybe for the worse? Idk, it sounds interesting.
|
|
|
Post by Woofzie on Feb 26, 2017 20:20:19 GMT -5
I don't want a Reedstar... He's so old.
|
|
|
Post by ❅Maplefrost❅ on Feb 26, 2017 20:25:34 GMT -5
I don't want a Reedstar... He's so old. Now that I think about it...he is pretty old isn't he? He was a kit around when the beginning of the series, so he's as old as Cloudtail probably?
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 26, 2017 20:32:58 GMT -5
ThunderClan: Squirrelflight why? she's so old like make it someone young not squirrelflight who woulda been in the elders den if we were in the first series RiverClan: Reedwhisker old and not very talked about (like the rest of RiverClan now). give us a riverclanner with Personality™, is young, make them deputy, and there ya go. ShadowClan: Tigerheart ew no why him has he ever shown ANY deputy abilities before god WindClan: Harespring eh. i think nobody cares about him because all of WindClan right now is onestar, crowfeather, breezepelt, and heathertail and we don't hear about anyone else that much :///// SkyClan: Hawkwing i've only skimmed through his SE and he looks ok
also: we need more female leaders like all we have is mistystar and she's never relevant- just like the rest of riverclan nowadays
i actually disagree with tawnypelt as shadowclan leader because she's pretty much ancient
|
|
|
Post by Jaysnow on Feb 26, 2017 21:08:43 GMT -5
ThunderClan: Squirrelflight-she does her job quite well, is definitely suited for deputy. But I don't think she's made out to be a good leader. I think Ivypool is much better suited.
RiverClan: Reedwhisker- Don't know much about him. RiverClan barely gets any screentime as is. Probably would be a good leader.
WindClan: Harespring- definitely going to be a fantastic leader. Really suited for the job. I hope Breezepelt becomes his deputy just so he can die (The First Deputies Curse), and Sedgewhisker succeeds him.
ShadowClan: Tigerheart- Hard to tell, he hasn't had much screentime as deputy, but he would make a good deputy and leader, given his past. I hope he becomes leader.
SkyClan: Hawkwing- Very suited for deputy, and eventually leader. We should get Hawkstar by the time the series is done. I hope he appoints Bellaleaf as his deputy.
|
|
|
Post by Woofzie on Feb 27, 2017 1:06:31 GMT -5
I don't want a Reedstar... He's so old. Now that I think about it...he is pretty old isn't he? He was a kit around when the beginning of the series, so he's as old as Cloudtail probably? Yep. He's the oldest deputy in the actual series. That and the fact that he's Mistystar's son just puts him in my 'nope' list. I want someone new and young to be leader, honestly.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 27, 2017 4:20:41 GMT -5
Sedgewhisker's pretty chill, I could see her as deputy while Harestar becomes leader. He was kinda nasty in previous books but suddenly he's kind and reasonable and willing to go behind his leader's back to save ShadowClan. That's gotta be on purpose, and if I had to take a guess I'd say Onestar will be dead by the end of the next book. They're probably building him up to be the leader Onestar SHOULD'VE been-- harsh but reasonable, like a less violent Blackstar.
I'm pretty unhappy with Squirrelflight as deputy. I thought it was really badly written that Brambleclaw hated her for the entirety of OOTS and they make up within the last like 2 seconds of TLH and suddenly Bramble's making her deputy because he trusts her. Forgiveness is one thing, but realistically she'd have to work hard to earn back his trust. I'd be less annoyed about it if he made someone like Hazeltail deputy and once she died of that random greencough outbreak, THEN he promotes Squirrelflight. I don't want her to be leader. I think it'd be very sweet if they died together and opening up a new problem of who's gonna be leader now ??? I'd actually like to see ThunderClan democratically elect a leader using the stones as votes like they showed in Long Shadows. Ivypool would make a good leader. I'm not so sure about Berrynose, though.
I agree that Rowanstar doesn't look like he'll last. My guess is that he'll have an ~~epic showdown~~ with Darktail and they both end up killing each other. My hope is that once Rowan dies, Tigerheart will absolutely REFUSE to take the name Tigerstar and he'll step down and let Dawnpelt lead, but... I don't think that will happen, lol. It sounds like the DovexTiger love plot will become relevant again though so maybe he'll go live in ThunderClan and leave the leadership role to someone else.
I don't know about RiverClan though. Maybe Petalfur? And as for SkyClan, no clue. I didn't read Hawkwing's book.
|
|
|
Post by pastelpills on Feb 27, 2017 7:51:32 GMT -5
They're good choices except for Tigerheart.
|
|
|
Post by wheeledwarrior on Feb 27, 2017 13:23:19 GMT -5
The thing about Squrrielflight is that why would love for being leader, she's too old. As for who would be deputy instead, I'd be fine with anyone as long as it's not Lionblaze (not that I hated character, it's just everyone and their dog chooses him as deputy in fanfics, so I'd like something original).
Reedwhisker also has the same problem, but I'm not sure who would be chosen as deputy in his place because Riverclan is out of focus…
It's pretty clear that Harespring will succeed Onestar, but I'm not sure who will be his deputy.
I'm not particularly fond of Tigerheart and was hoping for Tawnypelt, but I can understand why she wasn't chosen because she was too old. It's also worth noting that Tigerheart does not have his leader name at the time of his Super Edition, so maybe Tawnystar could still happen…
Hawkwing is a young cat and has been shown to be a capable deputy, so I wouldn't mind if he succeeded Leafstar.
|
|