|
Post by potatofrost on Feb 14, 2017 23:07:14 GMT -5
Hey! How would you rank all 9 Super Editions? (Or at least the ones you've read)
1. Tallstar's Revenge - I've always liked Tallstar, I think bringing Jake in was a really cool idea, I loved the journey, and the hunter/tunneler divisions along with the greenleaf warriors was a really cool and unique twist that made it different from SEs that took place in the other Clans. 2. Crookedstar's Promise 3. Firestar's Quest 4. Bluestar's Prophecy 5. Skyclan's Destiny 6. Moth Flight's Vision 7. Hawkwing's Journey 8. Yellowfang's Secret 9. Bramblestar's Storm - I think that all of the SE's are very good except for this one. It felt like a drawn-out regular series book. Bramblestar is a really dry main character, I hated Jessy, and there wasn't much of a running plot. It's the only Super Edition I really dislike.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 15, 2017 4:52:26 GMT -5
Aaah that's a nice idea! Haven't read Moth Flight's Vision though.
1. Tallstar's Revenge 2. Crookedstar's Promise 3. Hawkwing's Journey 4. Yellowfang's Secret 5. Bluestar's Prophecy 6. Firestar's Quest 7. Bramblestar's Storm 8. Skyclan's Destiny
|
|
|
Post by Tas on Mar 12, 2017 9:32:42 GMT -5
1. Hawkwing's Journey 2. Tallstar's Revenge 3. Moth Flight's Vision 4. SkyClan's Destiny 5. Crookedstar's Promise 6. Firestar's Quest 7. Bluestar's Quest 8. Bramblestar's Storm 9. Yellowfang's Secret ... not sure why I didn't like this one. It just didn't SMACK the same way as the others.
But all in all, SEs are a million times better than sub-series books.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 21, 2017 21:36:20 GMT -5
Lemme start by saying that I thought Yellowfang's Secret, Tallstar's Revenge, and Bramblestar's Storm were all complete trash, so although I will rank them, I disliked them all on relatively the same scale. Also I have not read Moth Flight's Vision or Hawkwing's Journey.
1. Crookedstar's Promise 2. Bluestar's Prophecy 3. Firestar's Quest 4. SkyClan's Destiny 5. Tallstar's Revenge 6. Yellowfang's Secret 7. Bramblestar's Storm
|
|
|
Post by Rainstar on May 24, 2017 5:46:38 GMT -5
1. Tallstar's Revenge 2. (VERY CLOSE SECOND) Hawkwing's Journey 3. Crookedstar's Promise 4. Bluestar's Prophecy 5. Yellowfang's Secret 6. Moth Flight's Vision 7. SkyClan's Destiny 8. Bramblestar's Storm 9. Firestar's Quest
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 24, 2017 18:43:26 GMT -5
1. Mothflight's Vision 2. Crookedstar's promise 3. Bluestar's Prophecy 4. tallstar's Revenge 5. Hawkwing's journey 6.Firestar's Quest 7. Yellowfang's Secret 8. Bramblestar's Storm 9. Skyclan's destiny
|
|
|
Post by ashfire923 on Jun 22, 2017 7:00:37 GMT -5
1. Moth Flights Vision 2. Crookedstar's Promise 3. Bluestar's Prophecy 4. Yellowfang's Secret 5. Tallstar's Revenge 6. SkyClan's Destiny 7. Bramblestar's Storm 8. Firestar's Quest I haven't yet gotten Hawkwing's Journey but I can't wait to read it. It's the only book I haven't read in the whole entire WC series
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 25, 2017 0:23:28 GMT -5
Now that I have read MFV, here's my updated list.
1. Crookedstar's Promise 2. Bluestar's Prophecy 3. Firestar's Quest 4. Moth Flight's Vision 5. SkyClan's Destiny 6. Tallstar's Revenge 7. Yellowfang's Secret 8. Bramblestar's Storm
I thought Moth Flight's Vision was okay. I liked the story and I really liked Micah, but I hated the lack of...I dunno...PLANNING AHEAD? Seriously, Erins, Skystar's character was ruined here, and Gatherings came out of no where. It's like Path of Stars never existed.
|
|
|
Post by Sunstar on Jun 25, 2017 21:46:25 GMT -5
1) Crookedstar's Promise - all time fave 2) Moth Flight's Vision 3) Bluestar's Prophecy 4) Yellowfang's Secret - always wanted a ShadowClan POV 5) Firestar's Quest 6) Hawkwing's Journey 7) Tallstar's Revenge 8) Bramblestar's Storm 9) SkyClan's Destiny
|
|
|
Post by Tas on Jun 27, 2017 8:15:18 GMT -5
Changing my opinions:
1) Moth Flight's Vision 2) Hawkwing's Journey 3) Tallstar's Revenge 4) Crookedstar's Promise 5) Bluestar's Prophecy 6) Firestar's Quest 7) SkyClan's Destiny 8) Yellowfang's Secret 9) Bramblestar's Storm
|
|